China not ready 
to succeed the US as world leader, Latest Views News - The New Paper

China not ready 
to succeed the US as world leader

This article is more than 12 months old

Beijing prefers to take on greater responsibility, not leadership

Three days before Donald Trump's inauguration as the 45th American president on Jan 20, when he launched the United States on a protectionist course, China's leader Xi Jinping delivered a keynote address at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, where he issued a clarion call for economic globalisation.

Whereas Mr Trump said "protection will lead to great prosperity and strength", President Xi declared: "Pursuing protectionism is like locking oneself in a dark room.

"While wind and rain may be kept outside, that dark room will also block light and air."

The Trump administration is launching America on a seemingly isolationist course, abdicating responsibilities that the country had assumed and, in the process, facilitating China's move into the resulting political vacuum.

This is notably the case with climate change and trade agreements.

Still, China is not donning the mantle of world leader that the US is shedding, realising that it is not yet in a position to succeed the US as global leader.

In fact, Beijing had long taken the position that reining in North Korea's or Iran's nuclear weapons efforts or reducing Chinese carbon emissions were favours that it was bestowing on Washington, not responsibilities that it should discharge. Indeed,China saw the G-2 idea that emerged at the beginning of the Obama administration as a trap designed to slow down its development by making it assume greater responsibilities.

In 2008, when the global financial crisis erupted, expectations were high that China, with the world's largest foreign-exchange reserves, would step up and provide substantial assistance.

Instead, Chinese leaders took the position that taking care of China was its contribution to the world.

The world is not clamouring for Chinese leadership and China is saying that it isn't interested anyway.

Then-president Hu Jintao told the Asia-Europe Meeting that "China's sound economic growth is in itself a major contribution to global financial stability and economic growth".

Nine years later, things have changed.

China since 2010 has become the world's second largest economy. According to the International Monetary Fund, China edged out the US in 2014 and is already the world's largest economy in purchasing power parity terms.


In the interim, China has also launched its first aircraft carrier and established its first overseas military base.

The Chinese navy has undergone a rapid modernisation push and now poses a significant challenge to the American navy. Such developments have given China the confidence that it lacked a decade ago.

Still, China baulks at the concept of "world leader", preferring instead to say that it will assume greater responsibilities.

Asked at a Foreign Ministry press conference whether Mr Trump's policies may enable China to play a leading role in politics, trade and other areas, a Chinese spokesman responded: "I prefer the word 'responsibility' to 'leadership'.

"We are ready to work with all others and make our own contribution to resolving the problems facing our world."

In a rare admission, one Chinese diplomat, Zhang Jun, head of the Foreign Ministry's Office of International Economic Affairs, acknowledged that "if it's necessary for China to play the role of leader, then China must take on this responsibility".

But he made it clear that China was doing so reluctantly rather than out of ambition.

"If people want to say China has taken a position of leadership, it's not because China suddenly thrust itself forward as a leader," Mr Zhang explained.

"It's because the original front-runners suddenly fell back and pushed China to the front."

But even this relatively mild formulation was too much for some Chinese.

Global Times, the frequently assertive tabloid, published an editorial opposing a "world leader" label for China.

"In terms of negotiating trade rules, formulating monetary policy and market access conditions, China has gradually gained some voice," it said.

But while China is willing to continue to promote globalisation, the paper said, China is not willing to replace the US as world leader.

China, the newspaper said, is not ready to "lead the world" and the world also is not ready for "Chinese leadership".

This is a fair summation of the situation.

The world is not clamouring for Chinese leadership and China is saying that it isn't interested anyway.

Instead, China merely wants a bigger voice on economic issues, which it can no longer be denied in any event.

So, for the time being at least, the world will just have to get along without the US as the leader in all matters.

And China is right that the world is not ready for it to be the leader, except maybe in economic or trade matters.

Come to think of it, that's probably not a bad situation for the world to be in.

The writer is a Hong Kong-based journalist and commentator. Follow him on Twitter 

This article was published in 
The Business Times yesterday.

Chinaunited statesXi Jinping